CD Projekt RED reageert op The Witcher 3 "downgrade" kwestie
De release van The Witcher III: Wild Hunt deze week werd wat overschaduwd door de "downgrade" kwestie. Het valt namelijk niet te ontkennen dat de game, zelfs de pc-versie, er niet zo goed uitziet als wat we te zien kregen tijdens een gameplay trailer van eind 2013. Al snel werd door sommigen geroepen dat men de game opzettelijk mooier had voorgesteld om gamers te misleiden, terwijl anderen er dan weer op wezen dat dergelijke zaken nu eenmaal gebeuren tijdens de ontwikkeling, omdat de ontwikkelaar ziet dat het aanvankelijke doel gewoon niet haalbaar is in combinatie met andere aspecten van de game die men wil realiseren. Ook werd regelmatig geopperd dat de consoleversie van de game de pc-versie negatief zou beïnvloed hebben wat het grafische betreft.
CD Projekt RED heeft de lippen omtrent deze kwestie redelijk lang stijf op elkaar gehouden, al werd hier en daar wel gewoon ontkend dat er sprake is van een downgrade, al hangt dat natuurlijk weer sterk af van wat men onder een "downgrade" verstaat. Inmiddels heeft Marcin Iwinski, mede-oprichter van de studio, tegenover Eurogamer echter wel uitgebreid gereageerd op de kwestie. Hieronder vind je het volledige stuk, maar samengevat komt het erop neer dat CD Projekt RED effectief de VGX-trailer als doel had gesteld, maar dat gaandeweg bleek dat zulke graphics niet haalbaar waren in combinatie met de grote wereld van The Witcher III: Wild Hunt. Men geeft dus toe dat de game er nu inderdaad anders uitziet, maar dat dit nu eenmaal zo gaat tijdens de ontwikkeling van een game en dat men de graphics dus niet bewust verkeerd heeft voorgesteld. Wel zal men in de toekomst nog extra grafische mogelijkheden voor de pc-versie voorzien, onder meer door spelers toe te laten de .ini bestanden aan te passen.
Did the console versions restrict the PC version?"If the consoles are not involved there is no Witcher 3 as it is," answers Marcin Iwinski, definitively. "We can lay it out that simply. We just cannot afford it, because consoles allow us to go higher in terms of the possible or achievable sales; have a higher budget for the game, and invest it all into developing this huge, gigantic world. "Developing only for the PC: yes, probably we could get more [in terms of graphics] as there would be nothing else - they would be so focused, like if we would develop only on Xbox One or PlayStation 4. But then we cannot afford such a game." Why did the graphics change?"If you're looking at the development process," Iwinski begins, "we do a certain build for a tradeshow and you pack it, it works, it looks amazing. And you are extremely far away from completing the game. Then you put it in the open-world, regardless of the platform, and it's like 'oh shit, it doesn't really work'. We've already showed it, now we have to make it work. And then we try to make it work on a huge scale. This is the nature of games development." It was captured PC footage, not pre-rendered, Badowski confirms, but a lot had to change. "I cannot argue - if people see changes, we cannot argue," Adam Badowski says, "but there are complex technical reasons behind it. "Maybe it was our bad decision to change the rendering system," he mulls, "because the rendering system after VGX was changed." There were two possible rendering systems but one won out because it looked nicer across the whole world, in daytime and at night. The other would have required lots of dynamic lighting "and with such a huge world simply didn't work". It's a similar story for environments, and their texture sizes and incidental objects. It was a trade-off between keeping that aspect of them or their unique, handmade design. And the team chose the latter. The data-streaming system couldn't handle everything while Geralt galloped around. The billowing smoke and roaring fire from the trailer? "It's a global system and it will kill PC because transparencies - without DirectX 12 it does't work good in every game." So he killed it for the greater good, and he focused on making sure the 5000 doors in Novigrad worked instead. "People are saying that 2013 was better but actually there's plenty of things that improved since 2013," Michal Platkow-Gilewski points out. "Size of the world, frames-per-second..." "Yes!" realises Adam Badowski. "The game's performance: people say the game is well optimised. This is the first time for this company!" It's the first smile I've seen from him all interview. Marcin Iwinski picks it up: "Maybe we shouldn't have shown that [trailer], I don't know, but we didn't know that it wasn't going to work, so it's not a lie or a bad will - that's why we didn't comment actively. We don't agree there is a downgrade but it's our opinion, and gamers' feeling can be different. If they made their purchasing decision based on the 2013 materials, I'm deeply sorry for that, and we are discussing how we can make it up to them because that's not fair. "It's very important to stress: we are continuously working on the PC version, and we will be adding a lot of stuff, and there is more to come. We've proven it in the past that we support our games and we will be looking at the feedback and trying to make it better." Why didn't you say anything until now?"Frankly speaking because we didn't see it as a problem," Iwinski admits. They didn't ignore the issue: every tweet, every mention of the issue for weeks now has been sent to the tech team to immediately address - and I've seen firsthand how closely they monitor everything said about the game and how much they care. "You're saying that we should have said 'hey we've changed stuff and now it looks like this'?" he asks. As it was, I tell him, it looked like CD Projekt Red had something to hide. "So actually here we strongly disagree," he returns, "because we are not trying to hide anything." You can't hide what people can so easily compare and see, adds Badowski. "We don't feel good about it," Iwinski adds, "and I treat it very personally. Maybe it doesn't seem [like that] because we run around like crazy at the release but..." "The whole team was touched by this," Michal Platkow-Gilewski chimes in, and I can testify to that. "They really care," says Badowski. Marcin Iwinski adds: "You play it and you are not fine: really, that's touching and we'll do our best to make it up. But if you didn't play it and you're trolling: think twice please. "In a way, because of us not seeing it as a problem, and working hard on the game until the very end, that's where we are today and that's why we have to explain. I hope it shows our intentions, because we are not hiding anything. Considering our values, hiding is the last thing we ever want to do. "And for those who are still not 100 per cent decided, I definitely encourage them to wait and see what we will be releasing in patches, updates and whatnot." |
